Buffett’s Longer-Term Slump: Time To Rethink Value Investing? – Forbes

WASHINGTON – NOVEMBER 14: Berkshire Hathaway Chairman and CEO Warren Buffett listens during a … [+] hearing before the Senate Finance Committee November 14, 2007 on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC. The hearing was to examine the uncertainty in federal estate tax planning under current law which will change every year from 2008 through 2011. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)

Getty Images

As a steadfast proponent of value investing, I align myself with a philosophy celebrated for its intelligence and deep-rooted connection to the legends of the investing world. Go figure. Yet my approach diverges from the traditional path. For years, I have advocated a bold, perhaps controversial stance: traditional value investing, as we know it, has run its course. It’s time to broaden our perspective and redefine what value investing truly means in today’s rapidly evolving market landscape.

Berkshire Hathaway’s stock performance has grown on the principles of value investing but it’s been laggiing. 2023 is ending on a less than stellar note, with Warren Buffett’s renowned conglomerate increasing around 16% this year, a figure modest in comparison to the S&P 500’s approximate total return of 26%

Over the past decade, Berkshire Hathaway’s shares have grown at an annualized rate of 12%, marginally trailing the S&P 500’s annual total return of just over 12%, which includes dividends. Additionally, in the last five years, Berkshire has underperformed compared to the S&P 500, achieving an annualized return of 13.4% against the index’s 16.4%.

Value Investing

Value investing aims to acquire stocks at a reduction relative to their perceived market value, as opposed to their intrinsic value. Value investing is predicated on identifying low-priced companies with sound fundamentals that the market is neglecting. Certain investors hold the view that variations in stock prices are not significantly influenced by the long-term fundamentals of a company, as the market exhibits an excessively pronounced reaction to both positive and negative news. In value investing, capitalizing on the discrepancy between the present market price of a stock and its intrinsic value is the objective.

Benjamin Graham, regarded by many as the “father of value investing,” was a pioneer in the fields of finance and investments. His influential works and lectures established value investing as a discipline after his birth in 1894. His 1949 masterpiece, “The Intelligent Investor,” is widely regarded as a classic in the investment world. One of Benjamin Graham’s disciples was Warren Buffett, the most famous value investor of all time. Based on Graham’s teachings, Buffett seeks out companies that are undervalued in the market but have solid business plans and can develop in the long run. When he proposed using a company’s brand value and market leadership in the calculation of intrinsic value, he revolutionized value investing.

Success Stories With Value Investing

Whenever I speak about traditional value investing in a detrimental way, I always feel like I’m attacking a cult. The success of historical people and funds are immersed in the strategy. A remarkable example of someone who has succeeded at value investing is Peter Lynch. During his time as manager of the Magellan Fund at Fidelity Investments (1977–1990), the fund not only beat the S&P 500 but also became the best-performing mutual fund in the world. Along with the remarkable returns of Seth Klarman and Walter Schloss, Lynch’s 29.2% average yearly return highlights the significant long-term advantages that value investing can produce with careful preparation and thorough study.

The foundation of many prosperous funds has been this investing method. Over the years, Oakmark Funds and Tweedy, Browne Company have shown remarkable skill in spotting cheap companies and profiting from them, even when the market has been volatile. In a similar vein, Bill Miller, the manager of Sequoia Fund, has expertly combined growth and value strategies. Sequoia Fund has proven time and again that value investing can be successful in a variety of market situations by focusing on undervalued, growing firms.

155006 04: FILE PHOTO: Investment guru Peter Lynch poses for a photograph in 1993. (Photo by James … [+] Schnepf/Liaison)

Getty Images

Evolving Markets

World markets have changed a lot because of new investment tools, globalization, and progress in technology. Technology has changed markets, investing strategies, and the expansion of tech-focused businesses. Fintech and algorithmic trade have opened markets and made them more efficient and linked. Globalization has made it easier for people to get into financial markets, which lets investors spread their money across countries and get into new economies. Adding global unity to markets makes them more volatile and sensitive to events happening around the world. New financial tools, such as ETFs, derivatives, and cryptocurrencies, have made trading easier and given people more options. These instruments give investors more ways to diversify their portfolios, but they also bring up new problems and things to think about. The effects of these factors on global markets have made them more interconnected, dynamic, and complex. This has created new chances and challenges for investors.

Social media has changed investing by making financial information available to everyone and connecting investors in ways that have never been seen before. Twitter, Reddit, and other finance-related sites have become important places to get real-time market news, analysis, and feedback from investors. These routes make it easy for information to spread quickly, which can have a big effect on market trends and the movements of individual stocks. Notably, social media has given regular investors more power by giving them access to resources and conversations that were once only open to professionals. This has made investor groups smarter and more active. Additionally, this opening up to everyone has given rise to things like meme stocks, where group discussions and hype on websites like Reddit can result in significant but frequently unstable market changes. There are some problems with using social media for shopping, though. For example, it can spread false information and make people follow the crowd, which can make them trade without thinking. Overall, social media has become an important part of investing. It has changed how people share information and make investment choices, which in turn has changed how modern financial markets work.

Challenges To Traditional Methods

Modern market changes, especially the fact that interest rates are relatively low despite recent rises and the prices of tech stocks are going through the roof, have made traditional value buying very hard to do. Low interest rates have made safe investments like bonds less appealing. As a result, investors are looking for better returns in stocks, even in overvalued tech stocks. This change has messed up the usual way of value investing, which is to buy securities that are undervalued and have a safety cushion. Value investors, who usually look at real financial numbers, are having a hard time with the sky-high prices of many tech companies, which are based on growth forecasts rather than current earnings. Value investors have had to rethink and change their strategies to keep up with the changing market conditions. They now combine old-fashioned ideas with knowledge of new economic facts and sector trends.

So, bring this up to the modern day and many of the greats are not living up to their greatness. David Einhorn is known as a value investor at Greenlight Capital, but the fund has struggled to keep up with market trends, largely due to Einhorn’s positions against the booming tech stocks. During growth stock market epochs, value investing legend Howard Marks of Oaktree Capital Management had it bad. Not only that, but the market overall has beaten many value-oriented mutual funds, including those run by Dodge & Cox. This is because the market is generally driven by growth areas like technology.

Kiev, Ukraine – June 12, 2014: A logotype collection of well-known world top companies of computer … [+] technologies on a monitor screen. Include Google, Apple, Microsoft, Intel and other logos.


How To Position Yourself Now

The use of numbers alone to make decisions introduces certain constraints into value investing, which has historically relied substantially on numerical research to ascertain the intrinsic worth of a stock. This method frequently ignores intangibles like the caliber of the company’s leadership, the power of the brand, and the dynamics of the market. The fact that technology and customer habits are always shifting makes it difficult to use past financial data as a predictor of future success in today’s fast-paced corporate world. Also, conventional measures like P/E ratios might not be the best indicator of a company’s future success in developing industries because this approach could fail to account for promising expansion prospects. Understanding the intricate and ever-changing structure of today’s markets necessitates a combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis in contemporary value investing.

Three Ways To Make Money

Ultimately, there are three primary methods to achieve financial returns:

Insider Trading (Not Advisable): This involves acting on confidential information about future company events. A notorious example is Martha Stewart’s 2004 case, where she sold ImClone shares before a major FDA decision was announced, leading to legal consequences. Insider trading is illegal and highly discouraged.

Rapid Information Utilization: This strategy revolves around acting on information quicker than others. However, with the advent of the internet and advanced technology, individual investors often find themselves at a disadvantage. High-speed trading algorithms and widespread access to information have largely leveled the playing field, making it challenging to maintain an informational edge.

In-Depth and Unique Analysis: The most sustainable and legal approach is thorough and intelligent analysis, focusing on less-explored areas such as upcoming corporate events that are public but not yet widely recognized. This approach, which involves looking where others aren’t, is where our company excels and forms the core of our investment strategy.

How To Win

To truly excel in the financial world, there’s a fundamental approach: outsmarting the market while mastering your emotional responses. This might sound like two strategies, but they are intrinsically linked.

Having an analytical edge means viewing the same public information as everyone else but through a different lens. My 30 years of experience in dealing with spinoffs, managing funds, and generating research have honed my ability to apply a discerning value filter to investment opportunities. When asked about our edge at my firm, I often explain that we leverage publicly available information but interpret it through the lens of our seasoned experience. This could be a deeper understanding of a specific company or industry or a unique perspective on risks. This edge is about evaluating information more astutely, leading to a more informed assessment of the gap between price and value and, thus, a refined prediction of investment outcomes. The key is to utilize a range of tools that enhance this edge.

The behavioral edge is twofold. Firstly, it involves recognizing and capitalizing on behavioral biases in the market. This understanding helps identify when to act counter to the crowd, as in the adage “buy when others are selling.”

Secondly, it’s acknowledging your own vulnerability to these biases. This includes overconfidence and the human tendency to be overly pessimistic about negative outcomes, which are seldom as dire as anticipated. Understanding your own reactions to market fluctuations and extreme conditions is crucial.

In essence, smart investing isn’t about chasing an elusive perfect strategy; it’s about insightful analysis and better behavioral management than your peers. It’s about knowing where to look and how to conduct oneself in the market.

The ever-changing financial landscape has cast doubt on time-honored value investment practices. Berkshire Hathaway’s stock growth has lagged the S&P 500 in recent years, causing renowned investors like Warren Buffett to witness a decline in performance. Considering this situation, we need to reconsider the relevance of value investment in the modern world. Changes in global markets have created new obstacles for value investing, which has long been lauded for its systematic approach to finding cheap stocks based on their inherent worth. Low interest rates and astronomically high-tech stock values that don’t conform to conventional financial measures are two of these.

Value investing as a concept is still useful today, despite all these obstacles. Blending quantitative and qualitative assessments is necessary to react to new market dynamics. Adapting to new circumstances requires knowledge of more than just numbers; it also necessitates familiarity with leadership dynamics, brand strength, technology developments, and market trends. Focusing on untapped prospects and making use of behavioral insights can still lead to successful value investing, according to successful investors. Just as important as analytical abilities are the abilities to recognize and overcome market biases and to keep one’s emotions under check. The complexity of today’s financial environment necessitates that value investors adapt to the ever-changing market by integrating old ideas with new techniques.

If you are interested in learning more about ideas from my company, The Edge, drop me an email at [email protected]

Hi, I’m Investing